most recent trickles friends calendar user info slide back slide back slip forward slip forward
Trickle of Consciousness - Genre-lization
jkason
[info]jkason
Add to Memories
Tell a Friend
Genre-lization
When did "genre" become shorthand for "sci-fi/fantasy/horror"? Genre is simply an easy way to categorize works. While they don't have the obviously-fantastic elements of science fiction or horror, I find "literature" and art comics displaying just as many common conventions as does so-called genre storytelling. Self-styled non-genre storytelling just has the benefit of disguising its conventions as realism.

So while, yes, an environmental story may eventually suffer by the presence of a talking plant as its central character, it's just as likely to suffer from the introduction of yet another heartless executive, environmentalist pushed to extremes, or innocent child (usually suffering a terminal illness) who "understands more than we know."

Relevant anecdote: [info]stotangirl and I had a professor during undergrad who decided to forbid fantasy submissions in our fiction workshop. Fantasy, he said, encouraged lazy writing. The next week, JO submitted her affair story with the shocking twist.

Lazy writing is the result of lazy writers, and the absence of super powers does nothing to limit the trite plot twists available to them. Just because it's "real" doesn't mean I'm less likely to notice I've seen it all before.

Tags: ,

Comments
From: (Anonymous) Date: December 3rd, 2003 09:54 pm (UTC) (wanna link?)
Genre came to mean fantasy/horror/sci-fi when mysteries snuck around through the backdoor into Literature Proper. The genre books, disdainful of the intellectualism that renders the denizens of Literature Proper into scarce more than cliches hoisted and re-hoisted, maintain their camp outside of the suburb Comic Fiction.

The politics of the situation are quite dreadful. There's been talk of bringing Jane Austen back to write a definitive peerage of Literature Proper and its environs. The decision, however, is continually blocked by high-ranking members of the Critical Establishment- who find Miss Austen's works far too popular to be taken seriously.

In completely unrelated news: Stephen King has announced that he will throw his hat in the ring for the coveted title of Mayor of Literature Proper. He points out the incumbent, Mister William Shakespeare (who has been Mayor of Literature Proper for nearly 200 years), is rather creaky around the edges and suffers from extreme ego attacks. Mister King politely reminds Mayor Shakespeare that, despite the protestations of many high ranking members of the Critical Establishment, Mister Shakespeare did not invent the English Language and should, in the words of Mister King, "stop pretending that he was anything more than the James Cameron of his era".

Mister Shakespeare could not be reached for comment, but apparently both Elizabeth the First and Francis Bacon are preparing press releases.

Chad
see the single drop in the bucket or add a drop
time and tide
Back July 2009
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031
what's around here?
blogging along...
comics from the ether
power pack
news of the comic
on this page
Anonymous (no subject)
tags